Reviewer Guidelines
Reviewer Guidelines
Peer review is the cornerstone of scholarly integrity. These guidelines describe what Jurnal Manajemen Bisnis (Bhusman) expects from reviewers at every stage, ensuring evaluations remain objective, evidence-based, constructive, and ethical.
COPE-aligned Double-blind peer review Business research ethicsThe Role of the Reviewer
Reviewers act in an advisory capacity to the editorial board. Final publication decisions rest exclusively with the Editor-in-Chief and Section Editors. Reviewers are expected to:
- Evaluate submissions objectively, fairly, and strictly within their domain of scholarly competence in business and management.
- Provide constructive, detailed, and evidence-supported feedback that assists authors in improving their manuscript.
- Alert handling editors confidentially to potential ethical infractions, data anomalies, text recycling, or plagiarized material.
- Maintain absolute confidentiality regarding the manuscript and evaluation process.
Before Accepting an Invitation
Reviewers should accept an evaluation request only if they can confirm all of the following conditions:
The manuscript aligns directly with your research expertise in business management, marketing, finance, HRM, entrepreneurship, or Islamic business.
You are able to commit the time required to complete a thorough review within the agreed timeframe (normally 2–4 weeks).
You have no personal, institutional, or financial conflicts of interest that could compromise an objective assessment.
You will complete the review personally without delegating to junior colleagues or students without prior editorial consent.
Confidentiality Obligations
- Not share, copy, or discuss any part of the manuscript with anyone outside the editorial workflow.
- Not utilize unpublished concepts, survey data, or business insights for personal or academic gain prior to official publication.
- Never contact the authors directly — all correspondence must proceed strictly via the OJS portal.
- Delete or destroy all downloaded manuscript files after submitting the review report.
What to Evaluate
Reviewers should assess both strengths and areas requiring improvement across all manuscript sections:
| Section | Core Questions to Consider |
|---|---|
| Title & Abstract | Is the title concise and representative? Does the abstract clearly state the research problem, methodology, findings, and managerial implications? |
| Introduction | Is the background well-situated within current business and management discourse? Is the theoretical/empirical research gap clearly established? |
| Methodology | Is the research design sound? Are sampling techniques, measurement scales, validity, reliability (e.g., PLS-SEM/regression), and analytical tools clearly documented? |
| Results & Discussion | Are findings clearly presented using formatted tables (no raw software screenshots)? Are empirical results critically compared against previous global literature? |
| Conclusion & Implications | Do conclusions derive directly from empirical findings? Are practical managerial recommendations for business practitioners and organizations clearly highlighted? |
| References | Are references up-to-date (predominantly last 10 years, >80% journal articles) and formatted strictly in APA 7th Edition? |
Research Ethics & Corporate Data Confidentiality
In business and management research, reviewers must exercise vigilance regarding research ethics and data transparency:
Surveys, interviews, or behavioral experiments involving consumers, employees, or managers must confirm informed consent.
Case studies involving private organizations or proprietary financial records must have written authorization or proper pseudonymization.
Reviewers must never upload confidential manuscripts into public AI tools (e.g., ChatGPT) as this violates author copyright and data privacy.
Submitting Review Recommendations
The manuscript meets publishing standards without requiring substantive conceptual modifications.
The core research is sound; requires small textual improvements, literature updates, or clarity adjustments.
Strong potential, but requires significant theoretical restructuring or empirical re-analysis; subject to re-review.
Fatal methodological flaws, serious scope mismatch, or fundamental integrity issues that revisions cannot resolve.
Editorial Office Support
For any questions regarding reviewer assignments, evaluation deadline extensions, or ethical suspicions, please contact the Editor-in-Chief via official correspondence at: [email protected].
