Complaints & Appeals

Complaints, Appeals & Post-Publication Discussions

Jurnal Manajemen Bisnis (Bhusman) • STEI Permata • COPE Scientific Debate Standards

Jurnal Manajemen Bisnis (Bhusman), published by STEI Permata, recognizes that academic communication does not end upon article publication. Rigorous intellectual debate, replication studies, and constructive critiques are vital drivers of progress in business management, marketing, finance, and entrepreneurship research. The journal provides transparent channels for scholarly discussion and procedural appeals in compliance with the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Channels for Post-Publication Discussion

1. Letters to the Editor / Commentaries

Researchers and readers may submit formal academic commentaries critiquing the methodology, statistical analysis, or theoretical findings of an article published in Bhusman. Submissions must be evidence-based and scholarly.

2. Author Response & Rebuttal

When a critical commentary is accepted, the original authors will be invited to submit an official rebuttal. Whenever possible, both the critique and the response will be published concurrently in the following issue.

3. Direct Author Correspondence

Readers seeking clarification on empirical models (e.g., PLS-SEM, regression), measurement scales, or dataset access may correspond directly with the corresponding author via the email published in the article metadata.

Criteria for Submitting Academic Critiques

  • Timeliness: The critique must address an article published in Bhusman within the preceding 24 months.
  • Tone & Constructiveness: Must maintain a professional, objective academic tone. Personal attacks, defamatory statements, or unverified claims will be rejected immediately.
  • Length & References: Typically between 1,000–1,500 words with a maximum of 10 primary references.
  • Peer Review: Commentaries and author responses undergo editorial review and blind peer evaluation prior to publication.

Editorial Appeals and Grievances

Authors who believe a rejection decision resulted from a critical misunderstanding of the methodology or clear reviewer bias may submit an appeal to the Editor-in-Chief. The appeal must outline specific, factual rebuttals rather than general dissatisfaction. Valid appeals are assigned to an independent senior editor uninvolved in the initial decision.

How to Submit a Comment or Appeal

Interested scholars wishing to contribute to post-publication discussions or submit an appeal should email the editorial office with supporting documentation:

Email: [email protected]
Subject Line: [Post-Publication Discussion / Appeal] – Article Title & DOI